Skip to content

About us

eCounsel group

A boutique firm with unparalleled expertise in business and technology. We have good command of industrial ecology and legal practice, and have undertaken highly regarded cases. Because the small business scope, we pay more emphasis on effectiveness and efficiency, and choose clients with deliberation. The managing partner not only has extensive experiences in various legal issues more over than 20 years, but invests and manages several technology companies. In addition, he always checks each case rigorously. Clients’ business objectives are our primary focus. To achieve the same in the most cost-effective fashion trumps all seemingly sophisticated legal discussions.

Healthcare vs. Drug Price

2015 - 12 - 09

Media in Taiwan has been reporting that drug price investigations result in low drug prices and pharmaceutical companies threaten to leave Taiwan.


台灣諸多媒體,一面講因為藥價調查造成健保核價太低、一面說原廠藥要退出台灣,連續不間斷地放送國外藥廠勾結醫師所發表的業配新聞。

他們藉此恐嚇公眾,並灌輸有病也無藥可用的醫療困境。

健保在藥品這個問題上當然有大問題,我們也認為核價這件事情應該有更合理的彈性。但是,大家是否清楚,在台灣,醫師開處方箋過度浮濫(順應病人要求)、病人的部分負擔太輕(上限NT$200)、各醫療院所為相同病人開立重複藥物、病人持處方箋取藥後未服用而廢棄之比例過高等的情事,已經造成台灣健保藥費在健保總支出上占有25%的比例。

我們再看看這篇WSJ報導:

Specialty medications for ills such as cancer and multiple sclerosis are so pricey that despite making up only about 1% of prescription volume at the University of Minnesota, they account for 28% of its drug costs, said Kenneth Horstman, director of benefits and compensation. Pharmacy costs are about 17% of its health plan’s spending, up from less than 14% in 2013

明尼蘇達大學給其現任及退休教職員與家屬(約39,000人)的醫療保險中,支付癌症和多發性硬化症的藥,雖然僅占處方箋的1%,但卻拿走了28%的藥費。2013年,藥費占全部醫療開支的14%,到2014已經到了17%,而17%,已讓老美陷入困境。

Another increasingly common strategy is “step therapy,” which requires that patients to be treated with lower-cost drugs before the health plan will pay for a more expensive option. This year, about 69% of employers had step-therapy rules, compared with 56% in 2011…

藥價年成長幅度近10%,高於其他醫療支出之成長幅度一倍。因此,愈來愈多的美國醫保方案,要求採用漸進式治療,也就是只准醫生處方箋上先開低價藥(否則不准核銷),如果無效才能再開較貴的藥品。2011年時只有56%的雇主採用這種模式的醫保,今年,升到69%。http://www.wsj.com/articles/employers-battle-drug-costs-1450488416

當然,還有其他措施,比方說提高病人必須自付的藥費的部分負擔。明尼蘇達大學已將最高上限調到了USD75,等於台幣$2,400,是台灣健保藥費部分負擔的12倍。

藥價與醫療保險政策,不是僅需搞定藥廠金援就可輕易解套。

Recommended article 

Thoughts on Third-Party Payment: It's a Fad

We have been through this topic in 2013. Third-party payment hasn’t been an “issue” in Taiwan. There is no problem to solve. 遊戲業攻支付 Q4激戰 「……目前樂點行動支付除將介接橘子集團旗下事業體,在全家、玉山、台灣大車隊、微程式等策略合作布局下,也將大幅拓展樂點行動支付應用場景,未來服務版圖將涵蓋遊戲、電商、P2P、娛樂、餐飲、交通、消費等線上至線下領域… 劉柏園表示,現階段將由自動找零的小額支付據點開始切入民生應用,讓消費者在販賣機、自助洗衣機、置物櫃、停車場等據點,能夠享受便利的行動支付服務,未來第三方支付也將成為集團營收主力……。」http://udn.com/news/story/7254/1218056 我早在2013年就講過了(http://goo.gl/DqJmEH);第三方支付,從來在台灣就不是一個「有待解決」的問題。沒有問題待解決,你想在這裡開辦事業,當然可以,但是,就得為消費者帶來新價值,否則誰理你。不論智冠歐買尬或橘子,想跳進來玩如果又必須創造新價值,唯一能想像的作法,就是像早期各家銀行為了衝信用卡的發卡量,所提供給消費者的各種優惠。 但是別忘了,當年銀行就信用卡給出優惠衝量,還有兩層的思惟:(1) 循環信用上看20%的利息收入、(2) 信用卡收單還有平均2%以上的清算清分手續費可收。 第三方支付呢? (1) 預付儲值,哪來的利息收入。(2) 悠遊卡能收取之清算清分手續費在超商這些零售點已經低到0.5%以下。 (更別提,悠遊卡還身兼交通票證,遊戲業有什麼?! 你要靠哪邊生出來的錢給消費者優惠?!)…

Sharing Economy: A Hoax or What?

“Sharing isn’t new. Giving someone a ride, having a guest in your spare room, running errands for someone, participating in a supper club—these are not revolutionary concepts.” – The MIT Press Sharing economy has been a…

Nose-Holders: U.S Voters Disgusted by Both Candidates

The president election is just around the corner. Only until last week, the poll hadn’t been in Donald Trump’s favor, largely because of his lewd comments on woman 11 years ago. Continue reading