Skip to content

About us

eCounsel group

A boutique firm with unparalleled expertise in business and technology. We have good command of industrial ecology and legal practice, and have undertaken highly regarded cases. Because the small business scope, we pay more emphasis on effectiveness and efficiency, and choose clients with deliberation. The managing partner not only has extensive experiences in various legal issues more over than 20 years, but invests and manages several technology companies. In addition, he always checks each case rigorously. Clients’ business objectives are our primary focus. To achieve the same in the most cost-effective fashion trumps all seemingly sophisticated legal discussions.

Counterfeits on Taobao, Not Affecting Its Commission

2016 - 05 - 25

Those who are buying products for cheap prices don’t really care about whether they are counterfeits or not. Putting a high-class, low-price product in the cart, they usually know what they are buying.

去淘寶撿便宜的,根本不在乎買到的是不是仿冒品;既然會把「低價、高規」商品放進購物車,對於買到的是啥,多半心裡有數。

The presence of counterfeits on Alibaba has been one of the major detrimental headline risks for the company.

Despite Alibaba’s efforts to combat this problem, the recent lawsuits against Alibaba regarding counterfeits has created uncertainties on the viability of Alibaba’s growth sustainability.

This increased uncertainty has contributed to the stock’s decline in spite of Alibaba’s Q215 and Singles Day sales that blew past analysts expectations.

However, Alibaba’s counterfeit risk is a trivial headline risk that has no material impact on the company’s fundamentals moving forward.

再者,法治國家的民事訴訟制度,基本上都是「不告不理」。雖然目前有Gucci, YSL等對阿里起訴,但所涵蓋產品連淘寶的萬分之一都不到;再者,考量美國打官司需耗費的人力物力之鉅,要是口袋裡沒裝個50萬美金準備給律師和鑑定證人等等的話,連法院的大門都別想走進去,小品牌,哪負擔得起。所以,只要北京政府不把馬雲蔡崇信打入大牢叫他們不准再賣假貨(你想可能嗎),淘寶上就將永遠充斥著高仿低仿,阿里抽佣,哪會受影響。

讀者或許會問,美國不是有律師打純粹的contingency(等拿到賠償金才見錢分帳),所以原告如果要戰,還可以在訴訟一開始的時候,先不必支出龐大的律師費嗎?沒錯,但那種律師,通常被視為訟棍、被稱為ambulance chaser(追救護車的,專指搶著找到傷患來委託自己打官司來賺後酬),不論在全世界各地,都會被法官和優秀的律師瞧不起,因此以這種精度和規模以及對手之強大的純商務案件,通常少有委任這種律師的。

因此,我的觀點是,較小較窮的品牌主,如果本件請求賠償並禁止BABA再犯的訴訟奏效,是否會聯合起來委託律師去制裁BABA,確實值得觀察。在那之前,如果我們不去究論馬雲的格調高不高、以及投資人對這支股票的觀感好不好的話,多賣假貨,是符合阿里之利益的,消費者更是開心,三贏之局,何樂不為。

新聞來源:
http://seekingalpha.com/article/3687806-economic-flaw-alibabas-damaging-headline-risk-counterfeits

Recommended article 

Microsoft & Uber finally face the facts and change their Strategies

Dara Khosrowshahi, an Iranian-American and the CEO of Uber, rolled out a new set of cultural norms, including one that states, “We Do the Right Thing.” Following last year’s decision by the London regulator, he flew…

Procomp (Part 2)

If you are skeptical about the status of document management in corporations, we can take a closer look at another part of the criminal act in Procomp case. 讀者若還是對於企業內文件的地位半信半疑,我們可以再來看看博達案的另一部分犯罪事實。在博達所假造的五大代理商應收帳款過高[1],已經逾期且無法用循環假交易收回的情況下,葉素菲與Commonwealth Bank of Australia(澳洲聯邦銀行)高層互相串通,設計衍伸性金融商品來掩飾過多的逾期應收帳款。首先,博達先將五家假銷貨代理商的債權賣給CTB AUSTRALIA LTD(簡稱CTB)公司(Commonwealth Bank of…

Internal Auditing Staff Unqualified

Guess what’s the average salary for an internal auditor? And what’s the reasonable salary for the position? 請讀者猜猜看稽核人員的平均月薪資是多少?再請讀者猜猜看,要找到真正適任的稽核人員(適任之標準請參考以下說明)合理的月薪又是多少? 由於稽核人員之日常作業其獨立性很高且必須獨立就受查單位完成稽核報告(或初稿),所以公司裡面的稽核人員不能只有少數一兩位,而是應該要每一個稽核人員都要具備以下的專業能力與人格特質。 最理想的稽核人員必須具備之專業能力有幾大面向1 (1) 學經歷與專業證照 內部稽核是一個跨領域的工作,而且內部稽核人員又必須時常應付多變的環境,教育程度是一個稱職的稽核人員不可或缺的基礎條件。另外,越來越多的企業在僱用內部稽核人員時會要求相關的專業證照如內部稽核師、電腦稽核師及會計師等。 (2) 超然獨立與積極態度 內部稽核人員由於其肩負發現組織缺失並且改善的職責,必須具備正直的人格,而且維持其超然之獨立性,這兩點都對於稽核部門的整體工作品質有非常大的影響,所以稽核人員執行職務必須勿枉勿縱並且不受威脅、利誘。當然,內部稽核單位在組織當中的地位越高,越容易維持其獨立性。 (3) 公司營運流程及知識 內部稽核人員既然必須查核企業內的各種活動是否按照既定計畫執行,當然必須對企業內的所有營運流程有相當廣泛且深入的認識,包括企業政策、文化、環境及整體營運流程,否則將無法勝任此工作。 (4) 溝通協調與人際關係 內部稽核部門需要有良好的溝通能力。有良好的溝通能力才能與受稽核的單位建立互信、無衝突的夥伴關係,有助於內部控制制度上缺失的發現與改善,除此之外內部稽核單位與管理階層及董事會間溝通也須仰賴良好溝通技巧,方能使上級即時接收企業內的制度缺失並且予以改善。 (5) 稽核相關專業知識及技能 審計、法規、財務、會計、資訊科技都是內部稽核人員從事職務時需要具備的相關專業知識。 (6)…